Back to School makeup essentials

The Advertising Standard Authority (ASA) have banned a Facebook advertisement by Rimmel London. The ASA claim that the advertisement plays on young girls insecurities. Rimmel London claim that the target audience is not young girls but 18-35 year old’s’.

So, who is right? Let’s delve into the debate….

The ASA have removed the Rimmel London advert and ruled the ad implied wearing make-up (mostly concealer and contouring) was necessary for young girls. Rimmel London have strongly insisted that the advert was not meant for teenage girls but for those 18-35 and those interested in beauty, yet released the “back to school essentials” advert in line with the back to school period. Comments say it targets young girls using a pink, books and a fluffy pen. As much as I love Rimmel London, I am finding it extremely difficult to understand how a “back to school” advert during the back to school season is not targeted at those going back to school?

I also find the whole pink, fluffy “girly” advertising a bit old fashioned. Boys too wear makeup and not every girl who wears makeup is interested in lots of pinks. The advert feels early 2000s and outdated to me, especially with the ASA confirming it is targeted towards young girls. It is hard to understand how an advert like this from such a big company got through many layers of approval without anyone picking up that it might be in bad taste.

On the other hand is the advert that bad? Rimmel London is a highly popular and well- established brand, and the controversy apparently came about from only two negative comments. The advert features make-up and Love Island contestant Lana Jenkins who fits into Rimmel London’s intended audience and Love Island isn’t something I’d expect a young teenager to watch. Also can’t teenagers speak for themselves? High school is already a scary enough experience on it’s own and it’s the age of them starting self expression, many naturally start experimenting with style and make-up. Rimmel London have stated the advert was meant to motivate and build confidence. Framing the advert as make-up is used for insecurities ignores the fact that it can be a creative tool for self discovery.

A huge amount of teenagers are going to wear make-up whether people like it or not and who are we to say they can’t? A lot of high schools already have strict anti-makeup policies and over critical attitudes towards self-expression in make-up. This can damage a teenagers self esteem especially if they are using make-up to hide insecurities and there’s nothing wrong with them wanting to do that if that’s what they want.

In conclusion, I don’t agree that Rimmel have targeted 18-35 year old’s, their advert is far too obvious to be claimed otherwise, and other brand like P Louise who do also cater for the younger generation at least own it. I also do think there’s nothing wrong with teenagers wanting to use make-up to find who they are, however i don’t agree with Rimmel framing make-up as a back to school essential. There are currently around 1.3 million 11-15 year old’s living in poverty in the UK. It’s extremely difficult for some families to afford the extortionate school uniforms, shoes, coat, bag and everything else, which is why a lot of high schools have that strict no make-up rule, to stop those who can’t afford from standing out. Framing make-up as a back to school essential on an already very impressionable age puts pressure on them that they have to have it.

Let me know your thoughts in the comments.

References used:

All images from google images

video Rimmel ad Gets Banned #beautynews - YouTube

reference article: Rimmel London ad banned for implying girls need make-up - BBC News

Previous
Previous

Beauty Horror

Next
Next

Snatched. Rage bait or clever marketing?