Dupe or Copy?

MCoBeauty has once again been at the centre of controversy in the beauty industry. After they have previously been sued twice for their jupes of high end branded make-up products, they are still heavily critised for pushing legal boundaries today. Lets take a look whether the comments are justified.

One of the argument is that MCoBeauty is a well established brand in its own right. The brand has been around for years, previously selling their products in Woolworths, now a global brand. They offer dupes of high ended makeup brands, such as Charlotte Tilbury, for a fraction of the cost of them. This enables those on low incomes to be able to afford next to the real thing for much less. It can also boost sales of the high end product, for one it gives people. A chance to try out a cheaper alternative first and then they often chose to buy the “real thing” if they like it. Another positive is it definitely gives a talking point opportunity to the original brand.

However, if you compare the MCoBeauty Flawless Glow foundation and the Charlotte Tilbury Flawless foundation (yes, the names really are that similar) it's extremely difficult not to see that the MCoBeauty foundation almost hits the carbon copy mark. Whilst the MCoBeauty foundation is legal, is it ethical? Sure it's an awful lot more affordable than Charlotte Tilbury, everything about the MCoBeauty foundation is too similar. From the lids in the same colour and pattern, the bottle, the wording, the only thing it hasn't got is the logo, which is why it complies with all laws.

Other well known dupe brands are a lot less subtle with their “copying” techniques. Brands such as primark and Home Bargains, who offer duped high end brands for much less have been praised by critics for how good their products are compared to the real thing. Also whilst their products look somewhat similar to their high end sister products, you can see a huge difference between them. It also raises questions as to whether MCoBeautys dupes may cause huge issues with those with sight and learning difficulties who some, are more likely to struggle to tell the brands apart and may be looking for one and not the other, leading to possibly purchasing the wrong one. 386MCoBeauty has once again been at the centre of controversy in the beauty industry. After they have previously been sued twice for their jupes of high end branded make-up products, they are still heavily critised for pushing legal boundaries today. Lets take a look whether the comments are justified.

One of the argument is that MCoBeauty is a well established brand in its own right. The brand has been around for years, previously selling their products in Woolworths, now a global brand. They offer dupes of high ended makeup brands, such as Charlotte Tilbury, for a fraction of the cost of them. This enables those on low incomes to be able to afford next to the real thing for much less. It can also boost sales of the high end product, for one it gives people. A chance to try out a cheaper alternative first and then they often chose to buy the “real thing” if they like it. Another positive is it definitely gives a talking point opportunity to the original brand.

However, if you compare the MCoBeauty Flawless Glow foundation and the Charlotte Tilbury Flawless foundation (yes, the names really are that similar) it's extremely difficult not to see that the MCoBeauty foundation almost hits the carbon copy mark. Whilst the MCoBeauty foundation is legal, is it ethical? Sure it's an awful lot more affordable than Charlotte Tilbury, everything about the MCoBeauty foundation is too similar. From the lids in the same colour and pattern, the bottle, the wording, the only thing it hasn't got is the logo, which is why it complies with all laws.

Other well known dupe brands are a lot less subtle with their “copying” techniques. Brands such as primark and Home Bargains, who offer duped high end brands for much less have been praised by critics for how good their products are compared to the real thing. Also whilst their products look somewhat similar to their high end sister products, you can see a huge difference between them. It also raises questions as to whether MCoBeautys dupes may cause huge issues with those with sight and learning difficulties who some, are more likely to struggle to tell the brands apart and may be looking for one and not the other, leading to possibly purchasing the wrong one.

In conclusion, I don’t think there’s anything wrong with dupes. They’re a huge deal cheaper, making them a lot more affordable for the wider public. As a make-up artist who loves high-end brands, when i was starting out, I would have never been able to afford 7 or 8 Charlotte Tilbury flawless foundations for my kit. The dupes are an amazing way to try the alternative before you buy the real thing and Charlotte Tilbury herself is not scared of dupes, suggesting that they’ll never be the same. On the other hand I don’t agree that MCoBeauty should be marketing their products, so dangerously similar to the high end version. It’s okay to sell a dupe, no laws have been broken, no-ones hurt, BUT like I’ve said before, at least own it.

Let me know what you think in the comments.

Next
Next

Beauty Horror